New York Yankees

Build Your New York Yankees Baseball Card Collection

Building Your Ultimate Yankees Collection

Are you building a New York Yankees baseball card collection?  Allow us to share some must have cards that you may want to consider for your collection.  From modern gems to vintage legends & hall-of-fame players, we've compiled a list of cards that Yankees baseball card collectors want to have in their collections.  How many do you have?


Quick Page Links

CardShellz Protect What You Collect

- Article continues below - 

Yankees All-Time Greats

Click the photo to be taken to a custom eBay search for each playerWhen clicked you can use eBay to see the current prices and availability of these legendary players & cards.  All vintage cards will general queries and not card specfic.  Modern cards will be card specific queries due to availability. 

Please be very cautious when buying non-graded, high dollar, vintage baseball cards.  Many fake Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Lou Gehrig, and other Yankee greats have a significant number of high-quality forgeries.  For many of the players below, our eBay queries eliminate most non-graded cards. 

Derek Jeter

Yogi Berra

Whitey Ford

Mariano Rivera

Willie Randolph

Alex Rodriguez

Andy Pettitte

Bernie Williams

Ron Guidry

Roy White

Tony Lazzeri

Thurman Munson

Earle Combs

Robinson Cano

Graig Nettles

Brett Gardner

Bob Shawkey

Mel Stottlemyre

Don Mattingly

Reggie Jackson

Roger Maris

Jorge Posada

Pil Rizzuto

Charlie Keller

Aaron Judge

Lefty Gomez

Pil Rizzuto

Charlie Keller

Aaron Judge

Lefty Gomez

Current Yankees Roster

Ebay - Collect more. Spend Less.

- Article continues below - 

First Base - Anthony Rizzo

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Second Base - Gleyber Torress

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Third Base - DJ LeMahieu

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Short Stop - Anthony Volpe

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Catcher - Austin Wells

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Right Field - Juan Soto

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Center Field - Aaron Judge

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Left Field - Alex Verdugo

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Starting Pitcher - Gerrit Cole

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Starting Pitcher - Marcus Stroman

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Starting Pitcher - Carlos Rodon

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Starting Pitcher - Nestor Cortes

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Starting Pitcher - Clarke Schmidt

Must Have Rookie Cards

Bowman 1st Chrome

Memorabilia Cards

Autograph Cards

Prospect to Watch

Spencer Jones - OF, Age: 22

Bowman 1st Chrome

Autograph Cards

Jasson Dominguez - OF, Age: 20

Bowman 1st Chrome

Autograph Cards

Roderick Arias - SS, Age: 19

Chase Hampton - SP, Age: 22

Everson Pereira - OF, Age: 22